Skip to main content

Positive product criticism: you get a technical review, not just a price.

Design review

We go through your drawing before we quote, and look at what makes the part castable: wall thickness, draft angles, radii, undercuts, parting line, ejector points and tolerance requirements.

Advice before production

Design review: positive product criticism before pricing

You know what the part has to withstand, where it sits and what it is specified to do. We know what a steel die and a melt will actually give you. The review is where those two meet — and it happens before you get a price, not after.

The term

Why we call it criticism

Because that is what it is. We go through your drawing and point at what does not work.

The word “positive” is there because the purpose is not to send the part back, but to make it easier and cheaper to produce. The changes we propose are usually about less metal or a shorter cycle. Those are two of the things you pay for on every single part, for as long as the series runs.

Since the price is built on metal weight and cycle time, we would in principle earn more on a heavy part than on a light one. We propose the light one anyway. A part that is properly designed is a part that can be produced for years.

If you are a founder, or casting is new to your company, this is the step where it pays most to get in touch early. We also help you judge whether the part should be cast at all, and by which process. Call, or come and see us in Råde, just off exit 10 on the E6.

Want to prepare the drawing yourself first? Seven moves that make a part castable and Casting tolerances are a good place to start.

The checklist

The six questions we ask your drawing

This is not a secret, and we gain nothing from keeping it to ourselves. Run the list on your own design before you send it — the more you have cleared up, the faster we get to a price.

Is the wall thickness even?

Metal shrinks as it solidifies. If one section is twice as thick as the next, it freezes last and draws metal from its surroundings. The result is shrinkage porosity inside and distortion outside.

Fix: core out thick sections, or replace solid section with ribs. Ribs give stiffness without mass.

Is there draft?

The part has to come out of the die. Without draft it sticks, tears on ejection and wears the tool faster.

Fix: add draft to every face across the direction the die opens — including internal faces, holes and cut-outs.

Have sharp internal corners been replaced with radii?

A sharp internal corner concentrates stress in the part — it cracks there first. And it cracks the die, which shows up as flash on the part.

Fix: put radii in. They cost little in the casting and give both a stronger part and a longer-lasting die.

Are there undercuts?

An undercut stops the die opening. It is solved with slides — perfectly feasible, but that means a more expensive tool, a longer cycle and one more place for flash.

Fix: if the function can be achieved without an undercut, drop it. If it is necessary, say so early so it is priced correctly from the start.

Where can the parting line and ejector points sit?

Where the die splits there is a thin line of flash. Where the ejector pins push there are marks. Both are unavoidable — the only question is where they land.

Fix: mark on the drawing which faces are visible or functionally critical. Then we put the parting line elsewhere.

Are the tolerances realistic for casting?

Casting gives you a tolerance. If the requirement is tighter, the face has to be machined — and that means machining allowance, which is metal you pay for and machine time you pay for.

Fix: put tight tolerances only where the function actually needs them. A handful of critical dimensions on a part is common. Many more than that are usually inherited from a drawing made for machining.

More than castability

The review also answers this

Which metal?

Aluminium when weight is a cost or the part will be anodised. Zinc when detail is fine, walls thin, dimensions critical — or when mass is an advantage.

Which process?

Pressure die casting for thin walls, complex geometry and volume. Gravity casting when the part needs heat treatment or the series is smaller.

Should it be cast at all?

Sometimes the answer is no. If the part is simple enough for folded sheet, or the series small enough for machining from solid, we will say so. That is cheaper for both of us than a tool that never pays off.

Data sheet

What the review costs and what you get

Three practical points are not published yet: cost, turnaround and how the feedback reaches you. Ask us, and we will answer for your project. The file formats we accept are listed in the request form.

Series and lead time

Response to an enquiry
After a technical review
Formal quotation with final files
After a technical review
Indicative minimum series, pressure die casting
A few thousand parts per year or per order
Indicative minimum series, gravity
A fifth to a tenth of the pressure die casting volume
Typical series size in production
Available on request
Lead time from tool order to first sample
Available on request
Time from sample to approved series start
Available on request
Lead time in running series
Available on request
Available capacity
Available on request
Call-off and stock holding
Available on request
Added lead time for external finishing
Available on request
Prototypes and pre-series
Available on request

Quality

Code of conduct
Published — covering environment, health and safety, legal compliance, employment practice, ethics, supplier requirements and anti-corruption
ILO reference in supplier requirements
Yes — prohibition on child labour, coercion and physical punishment at suppliers
Norwegian Transparency Act
Not covered — below all three thresholds. Publishes supplier requirements voluntarily.
Confidentiality
A business principle — every product example on this site is anonymised, and customers are not named without consent
Industry membership
The Norwegian Foundry Technical Association
Certified quality system (ISO 9001)
Available on request
Environmental certification (ISO 14001 / Eco-Lighthouse)
Available on request
IATF 16949 (automotive)
Available on request
Inspection routines
Available on request
Nonconformance and complaint handling
Available on request
Scrap rate / on-time delivery
Available on request
EPD and carbon accounting
Available on request

Send the drawing before it is finished

That is when the review does the most good. A sketch is enough. You get an estimate after a technical assessment, and a fuller review once the drawing is ready.

Related capabilities

Tooling

We procure it, adapt it to our machines and maintain it. You own it.

Want us to look at your part?

Send the drawing and the quantities you have in mind. We look at wall thickness, draft angles, radii and parting line before we work out a price.

We count visits anonymously to make the website better. Google Analytics only loads if you say yes. Read more